On Books

All This By Chance

Vincent O’Sullivan is a renowned man of New Zealand letters. His is a long and lauded career, and I’ve avoided his fiction until now.I did, in fact, once, a decade or two ago, get as far as purchasing an earlier and much praised novel, Believers to the Bright Coast.  It has sat on my bookshelf unread, the covers never opened. You’ll likely recognise the type of book, the less than worthy motivation involved in its purchase. 

39349426This time, I was hooked by the title: All This by Chance. I’m interested in the randomness of life, the way we are shaped by chance, and that was enough to sustain me through what proved to be the most frustrating, challenging, and ultimately rewarding read in a long time.

The novel tells the story of Stephen and Eva, who meet by chance in London post WWII, their children David  and Lisa, their grand daughter Esther, and Eva’s aunt Babica. They are members of a family disconnected and isolated from itself, in part by the Holocaust and in part by the decision Stephen and Eva take to not discuss the past, to live their lives as if they had not learned, by chance, some of the family history.

And this is where I began to get frustrated. I wanted to shake those people. Talking’s important to me. I’ve spent most of my life believing  that if people just talked more then we’d all be better off. I’ve done a lot of talking, myself.

And yet, talking doesn’t always help. I know this. Interestingly, Vincent O’Sullivan knows it, too. In an interview published in The Writing Life he described himself as “reluctant to let on too much”.  He tells the interviewer, Deborah Shepherd : 

I don’t particularly confide in people about things that deeply matter to me … if you talk about something you diminish its importance.

And much as I wished these characters would just talk about things, much as I tended to sympathise with David’s frustration that more wasn’t done, if talking had been the choice taken it may not have provided a better outcome. There is the matter of language. Babica speaks German, none of the rest of the family do. Despite David’s bitterness over the choices made, those conversations he imagined, the information he craved … how reliable might any of it have been given the complexities and the limitations of language. 

Towards the end of the novel Stephen takes Babica, who by now is suffering from some form of dementia,  to see a doctor—an Austrian who is able to speak German with her. The doctor tells Stephen:

You should be grateful for how much she has forgotten, how marvellous it might be to sit in a room and to have the children liking to be there even in silence with her, the gift of of getting beyond language altogether (p298).

Indeed, what damage might have been done if talking had been pursued? As someone once said to me, if you’re going to lance a boil it pays not to get pus in your eye.

All This by Chance is a novel which is revealed layer upon layer. Sometimes it was as if I was reading poetry, sometimes an adventure story, and then a travelogue;  through it all runs tragedy.

I complained about this book while I read it. I told my husband there was too much description. “The sentence structure is a nightmare,” I said. ” It’s all going nowhere,” I grumbled.  And yet I persevered. 

Now, several days later, I’ve thought about it, I’ve re-read sections, I’ve read the interview mentioned earlier, I’ve thought about it again, and likely will for a long time to come. It’s proved to be the most rewarding of reads. That sentence structure, those descriptive passsages, that long, slow revealing of the characters and their stories, put together it  presents carefully observed truths about the human condition from a compassionate writer who trusts his reader to pay attention, to notice, to reflect.

In short All This by Chance proved to be an outstanding read. If you take it on, take it slowly, read it carefully, savour the language, and most of all trust the writer. You’ll be rewarded.

All This by Chance by Vincent O’Sullivan, 2018, Victoria University Press


18 replies »

  1. Unfortunately I can’t get his book at my library here in Denver. My favorite reads are usually escapist like Lee Child, Steve Berry, Thomas Perry, Baldacci, etc. or biographies. Any New Zealand authors who write that kind of stuff you would recommend?


    • Hi Steven and Annie, Thanks for reading and commenting on my post. That’s a pity you can’t get a copy of this wonderful novel. I don’t generally read the authors you mention—crime and thrillers not being my thing, usually. But that said, you could try anything by Ngaio Marsh. And currently writing in a similar vein is Vanda Symon. And just this week a new writer, Joshua Pomare, has burst on to the scene with his first novel: Call Me Evie. Here’s the link to the press release: https://www.noted.co.nz/culture/books/joshua-pomare-crime-writer-call-me-evie/ (I have’t read anything by these authors, myself. But both Ngaio Marsh and Vanda Symon are highly regarded writers here.)


      • Marsh was a fabulous writer. Definitely one of the “greats”. Can you believe I never knew she was from New Zealand! I’ll check out Symon. BTW – My wife, Annie, will be down your way in March for a few weeks. I’m actually putting all her stops on google maps today.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. I try hard to persevere through a novel once I’ve begun it, but a couple of times I’ve simply had to throw up my hands in defeat. I’m glad you ended up loving it. It sounds like one I’d love to read if I can make it one of these years to New Zealand. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

Nau mai, Haere mai. Come on in and join the korero (conversation)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s